What do you know about shades of gray? No, not the chic-lit erotica that has captured a place on the New York Times Best Seller list for 65 weeks (so far). I’m talking about that place between black or white thinking that can enhance open-mindedness, create calm and (perhaps most significantly) quiet our inner critic (perfectionist) by moving us to balance (reality).
What really got me thinking about this topic is a new series of advertisements for the Ford Focus automobile that has the tag line, “’and’ is better.” The idea being that with this car it’s not an all or nothing proposition. With this car you get options (read choices), leading to a better ride.
In one ad, a couple considers a world where the menu item sweet and sour chicken becomes sweet or sour chicken -- the outcome being a completely unappealing, if not totally inedible, meal. In another ad, attached below, two buddies consider the world of art if the only scenes available to a photographer are all- black or all- white. The resulting pictures, sunrise over Cancun are completely uninspiring all-black or all-white shots.
Why then if operating in a world of absolutes is so distasteful or uninspiring, do we sometimes choose to be black or white thinkers, and how can we change that thinking?
One short answer to the why question is that we gravitate toward a language of extremes (absolutes) because our word choice is most simply and clearly understood when we choose adjectives that tend toward one end of the scale or the other. Therefore, for simplicity’s sake we tend to identify things as clean or dirty, tall or short, new or old, calm or frenzied. And while for each of those sets of adjectives there is a middle ground, it tends to be slightly less clear. When we choose to describe things using less extreme terms, we often find ourselves needing more words, feeling a requirement for greater explanation and veering into a long and protracted conversation when a simple exchange of niceties is in order. Hence: the spoken shorthand of extremes.
In our heads – that split language can seem completely reasonable. What I have come to understand is that these black or white, all or nothing, thoughts tend to be vampires of sorts. They seek the dark recesses of our minds where they can rest in peace, gain strength over time and rise empowered to drain the life from our plans, dreams and aspirations.
The first step to taking on this Cognitive Count Dracula is recognizing it. Notice your black or white, all or nothing language. The next step is to get it out of your head and into the light of day by getting out a pen and paper and writing out the shades of gray. For example, if you’re beating yourself up about your new running program, get real with it. Somewhere between fastest and slowest is probably where you fall as a runner. List the options on a scale using a sentence completion approach:
I am as . . .
. . . fast as my neighbor Sam who runs a 4:30 mile
. . . fast as my five-year-old son
. . . fast as my twelve-year-old black lab
. . . fast as the winning crab at the Captiva Crab Race (yes, there is one!)
No garlic or crosses required. Just haul that bloodsucker out of that little corner of your psyche that it has claimed and expose it to the light of day. Recognize it. Challenge it. Extinguish it. (I don’t know about you, but I’m somewhere between Bolt and the crab.)
It can get a little silly, yes, and it most certainly will move you into the middle ground of balance. Try writing your range of options the next time you hear your inner critic whispering from somewhere deep in your head: best or worst, success or failure and anything that you’re prone to apply the “est” to (you know, fattest or skinniest, loudest or quietest, smartest or dumbest . . ..)
Just like I won’t choose sour chicken, or an all-white picture -- I’m not going choose an inner voice without options.
I’m going to hop a ride in that Ford Focus in a lovely shade of gray. You know, the one that has the turbo-charge and the fuel saving eco-boost. Are you coming?